Reviewing my images

After shooting with variety of lighting techniques and background, I had to review all of my images and narrow it down to few which i felt where the best and that best fitted the brief.

Using adobe bridge, I used to starring system to pick out what I felt where the best images and I was able to narrow it down to 4. Below are the 4 images which I chose.

The reason i chose the first one was because I liked the lighting in in and I felt it is correctly exposed. What I do not like it about it the fact that the blue tones are very dark which causes the bottle to lose detail.
I chose the second image because I felt the blue tones were lighter and there was more detail within the bottle itself. I also liked the central framing of the image and the reflection at the bottom.
I chose the third image because it is very different from the first too. This was created when I changed the background from black to blue. The reason I did not chose this image was because I felt that the top of the bottle was too dark and a lot of detail was lost within it.
The fourth image is the image which I decided to use for my final hand in. The reason for this was because I liked the way the bottle was sitting and I also liked the contrasting colours and tones within the bottle. The only thing I didnt like was the fact that the you could not see the lid of the bottle and that also half of the background was blue and I would prefer it to be all black but I felt i correct these issues later in the editing process using photoshop.